When did you identify with your race?
Apr. 2nd, 2005 11:08 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
I recently read a post in which a woman from the midwest in the US asked an entire community: "What's it like to be black?" The cries of horror, lectures, and congratulations for seeking out different information still ringing in my ears, I was struck with another question - when had I become white?
So now I put this to you all, my friends list - when did you become identified with a color/shade on the color spectrum and what is it like being identified with that color?
What's it like to be red, yellow, black, or white?
So now I put this to you all, my friends list - when did you become identified with a color/shade on the color spectrum and what is it like being identified with that color?
What's it like to be red, yellow, black, or white?
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:27 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:37 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:28 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:38 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:42 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:29 am (UTC)As a teenager, I used to think race didn't matter and there was no truth to stereotypes. As I grow older, I'm seeing there really are major differences in the races, and that stereotypes are often justified.
For example, at my work we have a soda dispenser with strawberry soda. 9 times out of 10, when somebody orders the strawberry soda they will be black.
Not to say that other races are inferior, just that they are different.
I don't get a major sense of identity out of what race I am though, I don't even think about it unless soemeone brings it up.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:36 am (UTC)I'm not following your reasoning, here. It sounds a lot more like trying to reassure yourself you're superior instead of recognizing your own unimportance through picking an arbitrary characteristic to point at and say, "See? Me better!"
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:57 am (UTC)I said:
"Not to say that other races are inferior, just that they are different."
The point was that races are different, not inferior/superior.
I already said I don't get much identity from being white, only a slight sense of pride which has nothing to do with feeling superior. I just like being white.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:03 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:09 am (UTC)So yes different, but not inferior/superior.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:13 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:24 am (UTC)I have seen this with my own eyes. I wish you could come with me to work one day so you could see how justified this is. You would hear black person after black person ordering strawberry soda, and you would see that hardly any white or mexican people order it. When black people walk in the door, I preemptively make some strawberry sodas because there's such a good chance that's what they're going to order.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:31 am (UTC)Your experiences are more important than dealing with people as individuals?
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 06:22 am (UTC)Reasons why? Who knows. I've never cared enough to delve into it and find out if there's something there, or if it's all just happenstance. More on this in another post...
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 06:01 am (UTC)I'm caucasian, and I think this is the best race.
If you think it's the "best" race, that does imply that you think other races are inferior. But then you said that's not what you said. I don't think this is something you can have both ways.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 06:03 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:36 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:45 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:53 am (UTC)I got a huge lecture and my picture was taken away, and for a long time I thought I'd been bad, though I didn't understand why. Poor Miss Maple. Of course, in college I was looking through one of my anthro books and ran across a picture of a man in Africa - oh I'm blanking on the tribe, but one of the ones around the Sahara - and he was black (blackberry, as my HS French teacher would say), and my first thought was, "Ha! There are SO black people, Miss Maple!" Never let it be said I can let an old wrong go forgotten. *sweatdrop*
That was the same class with the round table of students who didn't learn with the rest of us. I didn't realize until I was thinking about race some fifteen years later that they were probably there because their skin color was different. I just remembering wanting to know if it was ok for me to talk to them, and one time when I smiled at one of them and he just sort of looked away...
They always seemed so sad, but I didn't know if I could help so I didn't do anything. I feel vaguely bad for that sometimes, and wonder if they thought I was staring for some other reason and wished I would go away.
I rarely think of myself as "white" except around people who seem to treat me as if I'm "white," though. Like, in High School my nicknames were Vanilla Milkshake and Wonder bread (white, light, and full of hot air!) and I always felt inferior to my friends because of how rich and vivid their cultures and histories were. That really pushed me into exploring my heritage, and I do find a certain amount of pride in my Danish, German, Scotts-Welch and Scotts-Irish heritage. I have some of my clan tartan, and I covet the painting of the rulers of Denmark. I'm not sure any of this gives me much on the whole, though, in the context of how much pain people have suffered due to peopl who look a lot like me.
I honestly don't know if I'm racist or not. I'm not even sure what that means, in this age of people hiding their true feelings under a layer of PCness. I try very hard to be friends with people because I like them, and not due to any physical characteristics, but my circle of offline friends is somewhat disturbingly uniform in hue and that bugs me in a vague way in the back of my head.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 06:39 am (UTC)Where it goes wrong is when people start taking that a little seriously. Believing that one's race is somehow "better" than another, believing that because someone's male or female or from another country (or, in America, even another state) makes them fundamentally less of a person, shit gets all whacked.
By all outward appearances, I'm a white Jewish boy from the suburbs. But, culturally, I've never really identified myself as "white." I avoid check-boxes on forms like that wherever possible. Don't look at my skin color; look a little deeper. If you're lucky, you might just see me. Don't look at the fact that I'm white and male and think that I'm educated and somehow privileged. Don't assume that my skin tells my story; it doesn't. I don't live in White America, but I visit it on occasion. It's just not my home turf.
By that token (no pun intended), I more/less tend to ignore race from one day to the next. I keep having to refer to George Carlin's excellent monologue from 1990 or so, wherein he showed just how the ruling class is able to use race, sex, sexuality, economics, or insert-social-issue-here in order to keep the working classes arguing among themselves and keep their eyes off of where all the fucking money is flowing -- straight to the top. Simple theory, happens to work.
The more we spend time arguing about what makes us different, the less time we have to work together taking this country back. Who knows, maybe we just haven't lost enough of it yet to care...
Anyway, that's all for now; see you at the next pit stop.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 04:58 am (UTC)(But, in all seriousness - I remember being fed somewhat racist opinions as a child and never understanding them. As I've gotten older, I have noticed differences in the way things are perceived and handled by different races, but I am pretty sure that it has little to do with the actual color of their skin but just how they are raised to act as a result of their hue at birth.
I think the difference between races is that society has eyes, sees a difference, and beats it into children (through tradition and opinion) that the physical matters so much.)
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:17 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:02 am (UTC)My own pet peeve on the subject is when, in the name of "diversity", there's an Asian girl, a Hispanic girl, a black girl, and a very blonde, blue-eyed white girl. I have medium-brown hair and green eyes - what does that make me? (In fact, for much of my childhood, I assumed that my eyes - which actually are my best feature by far - made me ugly because "pretty girls in books" almost always have blue eyes, and the few that don't have brown eyes.) I remember thinking back to that feeling when I read an article about how nonwhite children are reluctant to play with non-white dolls and act as if the white dolls are somehow "better". The dolls I remember were usually blonde and blue-eyed (or sometimes black-haired and blue-eyed, or rarely brown-haired and brown-eyed), and it did - in a very subtle way - make me feel like I was un-pretty. I know it's not quite the same magnitude as being another race, but I think that gave me some empathy.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:16 am (UTC)Any ideas on a solution? To be honest, the check-mark diversity schtick always rather pissed me off because the "diverse" figures were almost always secondary characters, not the leaders - like a girl would be included, but just one and she was never in charge.
I'd rather see a wider variety than some sort of cookie cutter "diverse" set.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:37 am (UTC)And also unfortunately, those who embrace the idea of us pale-skinned folks connecting with our own ancestry (whatever it might be) are too easily confused with racist nutjobs - this is also known as I should NOT get the KKK's web page in a google search on "Odin."
But to me, embracing other cultures needs to mean embracing "white" cultures and cultural histories other than the classical Greco-Roman traditions and their descendants, as well as welcoming "nonwhite" cultures.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:05 am (UTC)Everybody else is not.
That's the only way it's ever been.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 03:32 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:15 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:43 pm (UTC)See, I sort of take issue with proclamations like "That's the only way it's ever been." Excuse me? What, are you an orphan? Were you raised by fucking wolves? What the shit does that even mean? Did you get picked on a lot in school? Were you ostracized? Did people call you a "fag" and beat you up? Did you not date? Have you always felt alone? Isolated? Like it's you against the world?
Because guess what, dude, if that's all you got, that ain't much. Misanthropic, isolated teenagers are twelve for ten cents. However, I've never claimed to be some special and unique snowflake, nor have I ever japed that I'm the only one who could understand my pain or empathize with some of the horseshit I've lived through.
Why not just hang up a sign around your neck that says "I am the Enigma!! No one understands me!! PLEASE FUCK ME!!"?
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:47 pm (UTC)No, actually, but thanks for the object lesson on cliches.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 02:35 pm (UTC)And it's "abject". ^_~ Not to be a grammar nazi.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:36 am (UTC)I was first identified by colour when I moved to my new school in Ontario. A lot of the boys were mildly racist and would tell me to go back to Pakistan. To which I would shout back "I was born in England you idiots!"
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:54 am (UTC)One of my problems with life the universe and everything is that I know about myself that I am uncomfortable with black people, though I do not know why this is so. My parents are not biased against them at all that I can tell, so I'm kind of mystified as to where it came from, but I don't act on my discomfort at all. I think it would help if I knew where it came from, but I've just...never been sure.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:57 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 06:00 am (UTC)Yes. Very ironic. ^^;
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 05:56 am (UTC)Anyway. My first realisation about myself was a giant lot of 'not' and it was related to ethnicity and religion more than anything else. I was NOT: Irish, Italian, Catholic or Jewish, while just about everyone around me was one or more of the preceeding. (My heritage is, in more or less equal parts, the following: Scottish/Northern British and Cherokee. There's a hint of Blackfoot in there for spice, and probably more than a touch of Scandanavian...as my brother put it when writing a report 'You know how the Vikings used to drag off women? THOSE WERE OUR WOMEN.') For me, this didn't mean much except that I was different, and I'd already known that, thanks. This was probably...oh, before I went to school, I figure. Maybe Kindergarten as a major factor, because of St Patrick's Day and a little quirk my mother had (see end note). I know I knew I was, as I put it back then, 'half Indian' by the first Thanksgiving thing we had in school (mostly because I got tapped to play an Indian despite being blond and blue-eyed because I was and because I actually knew a few words. Completely wrong language, however, which means that there are probably STILL kids from the Fisher Elementary School Kindergarten class of '88 who think that the Pilgrims were greeted with 'Osiyo'.) and there are stories about me when I was little (let's just say they're along the lines of my father thinking the 'Colored' water fountain gave blue water)
The little realisation I'd referred to in the beginning comes up here, though, because I'm pretty certain that my mother is actually racist in an anti-Irish sense. (She doesn't like Catholics, as a rule, she tends to be sneering, and she dressed us in orange every St Patrick's Day, which at first, when I remembered, I was a little snickery about, but after a second I went 'WAIT.' Especially because the Troubles in Northern Ireland is actually a big deal around Boston...see previous statement about the only things most people were. And this was in the late 80's and early 90's, when the Peace Process was still a twinkle in most people's eyes) I'm actually not sure how this might have effected things, but it says something about the fact that my conception of myself STILL has a major factor of 'Not!Irish'.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 07:09 am (UTC)And I know I'm a product of my environment. That doesn't make it right, and it doesn't mean I shouldn't not feel this way, but...agh. I don't think I am a racist, but I don't think I'll ever feel 'safe' when I'm the only minority in the room.
*uses the obligatory LOOK I AM COLOURED icon*
Oh, and it's never going to be okay for white people to say 'nigga'. I know it's hypocritical, even though I don't believe in using it--but all of them need to stop asking, because I will cheerfully join in on kicking the ass of any white person that uses it. See? How is that logical of me? But latinos/latinas can use it, though. Don't ask me why, that's just the rules, I didn't make them. If I had my way, no one would be using it. It's stupid.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:19 pm (UTC)Dude, coolest revelation evah.
Have you ever done the thing where you're doing somehting and you come up with, like, the perfect fade from that to some related thing that would happen, damnit if you were on TV? I did when I was a kid and was rather disappointed when time continued on directly instead of fading to that evening...
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:33 pm (UTC)Oh, good. It wasn't just me, then. Although, since it's you, too, that doesn't make it any saner...
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:45 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 07:12 am (UTC)When I finally learned was racism and such was, I was really, really confused. I just couldn't understand why people thought like that. I thought it was rather rediculous. I understand it's out there, I just didn't realize it was such a big issue until I visited places other than where I grew up.
Boy, was that frustrating. Even now I get annoyed when people make even jokes regarding race or being oppressed by some person or the differences between them and not the individuals. In my head somewhere there's a voice screaming "IT'S NOT THAT IMPORTANT."
Unfortunately, I learned what it was like to be moderately-well-off white in a world that was not like my hometown. Certain people don't want to associate with you because they think you'll have nothing in common. >:/ It's rather frustrating, because if they don't talk to me, than how would I know?
Looking at it, I admit that a majority of my friends have and are caucasian like myself. But I have and still have black, mexican, asian, etc friends as well. And it's because of who they are and not what they look like. Gotta thank my upbringing for that. :3
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 07:15 am (UTC)My dad was in the service and we were sent to the Philippines. A lot of the families living around us on the base were Black and Hispanic families.
So, I grew up in this weird situation(for a white American) where I was the minority. I think I had one white friend growing up. I was raised in part by a Chinese/Philippino housekeeper. I really thought she was family as a small child, I never saw her as different from anyone else I cared about.
My childhood gave me a peculiar case of color blindness in many ways. I remember when I was about 9 and discovered that some people actually HATE each other because they're a different race. I was stunned. Almost all my childhood best friends were Asian or Black. I ate at their houses, had pajama parties and shared their beds, and never even gave it a thought that we were "different".
It was such a shock to me in particular that some white people felt they were superior to people of color. I didn't know about being afraid of or hating people who were different. I still cannot relate at all to those kinds of ideas. It's very outside my personal experience.
I only felt "white" when I was much older, a teenager, and even then, it was because other people made that distinction for me.(I remember one funny incident in school where a black girl referred to me as "that white girl" and I almost looked around to see who she was talking about. It took me a minute to realize it was me!) I can't ever consciously thinking when I'm dealing with other people, "I'm white." It usually comes from the other person if at all.
Growing up the way I did does seem to have had an impact on my esthetics, though. I tend to find non-white people more attractive. Most of the people I've dated are darker than I am, usually Black, Amerindian, Asian or Mediterannean types. My husband has Black and Amerindian ancestry.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 09:37 pm (UTC)It wasn't until... around the time I was maybe 7-8 when, out of curiosity, I'd asked one housekeeper did with her head under the blanket at night. She showed me (and I think one of my sisters.) how she knelt at the foot of the bed under the blankets that draped there and would pray.
When my mother found us, she was furious. Again, I can't really remember all of the details, but I think she'd accused the woman of trying to teach us her religion.
I did notice one other difference regarding people's skin tones when I was young. Darker skin tended to be generally softer (sometimes a little greasier). I think that has to do with the oils in the skin.
Looking back, the schools I'd gone to were majority white/caucasian/WASP-ish (heheheheheheh. :) Didn't ever really matter to me. (I still remember an newly transferred girl teaching me how to write her name in Chinese.)
Later in life, when I really started to understand how much racism seems to be around (and I tend to be pretty dense/naive about things), the more I tried to watch my behaviour to NOT be so. I don't know if I just look too obvious sometimes, and most of my friends are white.
I don't know. I really want to believe that "peoples is peoples". ^_^
no subject
Date: 2005-04-03 10:53 pm (UTC)Anyway.
I grew up with almost no exposure to any race other than white and native. My best friend since age two is asian/czech, my other best friend is native/white, my girlfriend is all german, and I'm not gonna get into my own mix. My class sort of looked like one of those tv shows, there was a black girl, a black guy, a asian guy, a jewish girl and a baha'i guy. Everyone else except for a few mixes was all white and various flavours of christian. Anyway, everyone acted exactly the same. My opinions formed from that.
I've never really understood that there is a difference beyond visual and I like it when people don't try to show me, because it never ends well. THE END.
I like cookies.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 01:21 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 03:11 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 03:43 am (UTC)It wasn't until I got to high school and was exposed to the liberal-PC mindset that the white man is the devil and responsible for all the world's ills that the matter of race even became an issue for me. Thankfully by then I was deep enough into punk rock that such barbs were pretty much lost on me (NOFX's Don't Call Me White and Minor Threat's Guilty of Being White were planted firmly in my mind by then) and I had studied enough history to know that nobody's hands were clean. I was also a big enough jerk to not shed a tear over every conquered peoples or feel responsible for every dead non-white.
Gender was another matter. I never had male guilt, either, but growing up, the impetus to have male guilt was far stronger than that for white guilt. Men, I was lead to believe from early on, were nasty, brutish, thuggish creatures who were abusive to women and raped the world. That had a strong affect on me when I was young, and apparently it worked on a lot of guys my age; most every guy in my town that wasn't a redneck thug was a pasty, poetry-writing, hypersensitive girl-with-a-penis.
Being the utter fucking dork that I was, I opted for another route. I embraced the idea of chivalry -- the kind that only exists in fairy tales -- and tried to become one of those strong, noble men that grow up to be charming princes.
Clearly, I have lost my way somewhere along (perhaps not being charming or a prince has stymied me), but I think I have found an optimum equilibrium between brainless jock thug moron and hypersensitive poetry-writing well-groomed metrosexual poofter.
And for the record, I think women are fucking awesome, but I still wake up every goddamned day and exalt in joy at the fact that I'm a goddamned man.
All that aside, none of those things were my first taste of "Gee, I'm nothing like you people". That happened when I was quite, quite young, and had everything to do with the workings of my mind, and nothing to do with race, gender, sexual orientation or class. Although I was, for the record, an angry, angry, poor, poor, young man.
no subject
Date: 2005-04-04 02:31 pm (UTC)Oh it drives me nuts when people stereotype. Strawberry soda? How about all white people listening to country music and being unable to dance. If your going to believe in a stereotype, then believe in all of them, like a black man's endowment... poor poor white guys and their g/f's. Lol.